diff --git a/module/story/view/batchedit.html.php b/module/story/view/batchedit.html.php
index fee5c7e5bc..bd7684c5c5 100644
--- a/module/story/view/batchedit.html.php
+++ b/module/story/view/batchedit.html.php
@@ -101,10 +101,11 @@ foreach(explode(',', $showFields) as $field)
           </td>
           <td class='text-left<?php echo zget($visibleFields, 'plan', ' hidden')?>'>
             <?php
-             $productPlans = array();
+             $productPlans = array('' => '');
              if($story->branch != BRANCH_MAIN)
              {
-                 $productPlans = zget($plans, $story->branch) + zget($plans, 0);
+                 if(isset($plans[$story->branch])) $productPlans .= $plans[$story->branch];
+                 if(isset($plans[0])) $productPlans .= $plans[0];
              }
              else
              {