diff --git a/module/stage/model.php b/module/stage/model.php
index 267ef471be..6f96ca06a6 100644
--- a/module/stage/model.php
+++ b/module/stage/model.php
@@ -170,7 +170,7 @@ class stageModel extends model
             ->orderBy($orderBy)
             ->fetchAll('id');
 
-        $stagePoints = $this->dao->select('*')->from(TABLE_DECISION)->where('stage')->in(array_keys($stages))->orderBy('order_asc')->fetchGroup('stage');
+        $stagePoints = $this->dao->select('*')->from(TABLE_DECISION)->where('stage')->in(array_keys($stages))->andWhere('deleted')->eq('0')->orderBy('order_asc')->fetchGroup('stage');
         $pointList   = array();
         foreach($stagePoints as $stageID => $points)
         {
@@ -300,7 +300,8 @@ class stageModel extends model
         $stage = $this->dao->select('*')->from(TABLE_STAGE)->where('id')->eq($stageID)->fetch();
         return $this->dao->select('t1.*,t2.flow')->from(TABLE_DECISION)->alias('t1')
             ->leftJoin(TABLE_APPROVALFLOWOBJECT)->alias('t2')->on("t1.id = t2.objectID AND t2.objectType = 'point'")
-            ->where('t1.stage')->eq($stageID)
+            ->where('t1.deleted')->eq('0')
+            ->andWhere('t1.stage')->eq($stageID)
             ->andWhere('t1.type')->eq($type)
             ->andWhere('t2.root')->eq($stage->workflowGroup)
             ->orderBy('order_asc')
@@ -379,12 +380,7 @@ class stageModel extends model
 
         if(!empty($oldStagePoints))
         {
-            $this->dao->delete()->from(TABLE_DECISION)->where('id')->in(array_keys($oldStagePoints))->exec();
-            $this->dao->delete()->from(TABLE_APPROVALFLOWOBJECT)
-                ->where('objectID')->in(array_keys($oldStagePoints))
-                ->andWhere('objectType')->eq('point')
-                ->andWhere('root')->eq($stage->workflowGroup)
-                ->exec();
+            $this->dao->update(TABLE_DECISION)->set('deleted')->eq('1')->where('id')->in(array_keys($oldStagePoints))->exec();
         }
         return true;
     }